The transition from 'Batgirl' to 'Spiderwick Chronicles' exemplifies how unpredictable the entertainment industry can be.
Renowned screenwriter William Goldman famously coined the phrase, "Nobody knows anything," which he elaborated on in an interview a decade ago, emphasizing that predicting which movies will succeed is a near-impossible task.
Include "The Spiderwick Chronicles," a recently launched streaming series, alongside the unreleased films "Batgirl" and "Coyote vs. Acme" to illustrate how studios and streaming services still struggle to predict successful projects. This highlights the enduring relevance of Goldman's insight from his book "Adventures in the Screen Trade."
Adapted from beloved books that were the basis for a 2008 movie, "The Spiderwick Chronicles" was initially developed for Disney+. However, according to Deadline, the streaming service ultimately opted not to proceed with airing it as part of a cost-cutting strategy.
In contrast to "Batgirl," which was produced for Warner Bros. Discovery's Max platform (a sibling to CNN), and the studio's live-action adaptation of the Roadrunner cartoons, "Coyote vs. Acme," "Spiderwick" will indeed be released. Following Disney's withdrawal, the project was acquired by the Roku channel, set to debut its eight-episode first season this week.
"Spiderwick Chronicles" may not stand out as particularly unique, embodying the generic vibe of numerous similarly themed properties. It revolves around a family relocating to a spooky estate inhabited by mythological creatures.
Despite its perceived lack of uniqueness, the series boasts notable actors such as Christian Slater and Charlayne Woodard. Frankly, considering some of the content on Disney+, one might question why this project was deemed unworthy of airing on the platform.
Several factors contribute to such decisions, including complex tax issues, particularly with projects like "Batgirl" and "Coyote," where the potential savings from writing off the entire movie might outweigh the benefits of televising or distributing it. Ultimately, these decisions are rooted in the belief that these projects won't achieve enough success to justify releasing them, despite the uncertainty inherent in predicting a project's success.
Certainly, Hollywood's extensive history is replete with both unforeseen blockbusters and unexpected failures. For instance, the studio behind "Titanic" initially worried that James Cameron's extravagant production would tank just as quickly as the real ocean liner. Similarly, "Seinfeld" faced such skepticism at NBC that the network's head of specials, Rick Ludwin, had to sacrifice part of his budget to greenlight a mere four episodes. Yet, as the saying goes, the rest is history.
Goldman's passing in 2018 marked the end of an era, leaving behind a remarkable legacy with screenplays for classics like "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid," "All the President's Men," "Marathon Man," and "The Princess Bride." Although these works emerged from a different time, the enduring lessons about the unpredictable nature of the entertainment industry and the cautionary tale of studio decision-making continue to resonate.
The current volatility of the entertainment industry, marked by the uncertain economics of streaming and the impact of at-home consumption and Covid on box-office revenue, has heightened concerns about how companies allocate their funds. Even once-reliable assets like Marvel now appear to carry greater risk.
However, a genuine blockbuster—whether it's the next "Barbie" or "Avatar," or in the streaming realm, another "Stranger Things" or "The Boys"—can justify its cost at almost any price.
It's possible that Roku possesses insights that Disney lacks, or vice versa. Alternatively, the decision to acquire "Spiderwick," a recognizable title, may align better with the objectives of a less high-profile channel than Disney, which prioritizes showcasing its own properties. Looking at the bright side, this situation could be one where all parties, including producers and talent, benefit from the resolution.
In "All the President's Men," Goldman delivered one of his memorable lines through Deep Throat's advice: "Follow the money." However, with projects like "Batgirl" and "Spiderwick," tracing that financial trail has become elusive. This indicates that navigating today's adventures in the screen trade, whether big or small, has grown more perplexing than even a seasoned observer like Goldman could have foreseen.
0 Comments